The End of Clicks as We Know Them: What “Buy it in ChatGPT” Means for Affiliate Marketing
October 7, 2025Twenty years ago, affiliate managers were not discussing Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC). We measured success by clicks, conversion rates, and raw sales volume. The focus was on driving traffic and closing deals rather than dissecting the full cost of acquiring each customer.

From Clicks to Cost Discipline
When I first heard the term on a Zoom call, I had to Google the acronym and keep up with the presentation quickly. Watching CAC become a staple metric over the last decade changed the game; it forced us to think not only about revenue but about the efficiency of every dollar spent to bring a buyer through the door.
CAC continues to rise for DTC brands as paid social volatility, rising influencer rates, and attribution headaches make it harder to win every new customer. Yet a well-built affiliate program can quietly reduce that number without cutting spending.
The key is to stop treating affiliates as an afterthought and start engineering them to do real acquisition work.
The Case for Affiliates in CAC Strategy
The affiliate programs managed by the Apogee team over the years have consistently been the lowest CAC for our clients. We have been told this repeatedly during conversations as they compare our numbers to other channels.
Internally, we have stayed laser-focused on maintaining this approach so that we can transition clients from a 12-month contract to a 36-month contract. We have achieved this by implementing high-value content campaigns.
Think Long Term With Content Placements
Affiliate programs can and should partner with brands on paid content placements, but those deals must be viewed through a long lens, not a campaign-by-campaign microscope. When you pay to put your brand in front of a highly qualified, trusted audience, you are not simply buying one batch of clicks; you are planting a signal that keeps working.
Customers discover, return to, and buy again over months, sometimes years. That is why CAC is better treated as an investment benchmark than a single-period profit test. A content placement might appear expensive if you measure it solely against immediate sales, yet the return grows as that content continues to live on and keep sending buyers back.
The closer a brand can push its CAC toward zero relative to its average order value (AOV), the stronger its long-term economics, but that improvement rarely shows in month-one dashboards. Affiliate managers and brands who build these paid content partnerships with patience and data discipline end up with stickier audiences and cheaper conversions over time.
Recruit partners with true selling power
Focus on creators and publishers who actually influence purchase: comparison reviewers, niche content sites, newsletter curators, and mid-size influencers who convert.
Affiliates who simply list coupons will not reduce CAC; affiliates who educate, recommend, and target high-intent audiences will.
Invest in creative and conversion support
An affiliate channel is not plug-and-play. Supply partners with high-converting landing pages, product images, unique discount codes, and quick-turn creative that they can test.
Affiliates who can quickly incorporate new angles into their content will send traffic that converts more efficiently.
Use media mix modeling to see affiliate impact
Last-click attribution undersells affiliate value. When you integrate affiliate marketing into a media mix model, you see how their content supports other channels such as search, social, and retargeting.
That clarity helps you pay for what actually drives acquisition and reallocate spend to the affiliates and content types that lower CAC.
Pair affiliate with retention loops
CAC shrinks further when new buyers stick. Provide affiliates with tools to drive repeat purchases: post-purchase offers, referral codes, and VIP perks.
Partners can help deepen LTV, which makes every acquisition dollar go further.
The 2026 Shift
Brands that treat affiliates as a performance PR and customer-driven storytelling channel, not just a coupon afterthought, will see CAC bend down while growth keeps climbing.
Recruit strategically, enable aggressively, measure with modern models, and pay for the kind of acquisition you want.